Which genealogy software should you choose?
There is no best genealogy software in the absolute: there is the one that suits the way you research, alone or with your family, on a computer or on a phone. Here are the main kinds of tools, what each does well, and the questions to ask before you enter your first ancestors.
Four kinds of tools
“Genealogy software” covers tools that answer different needs. Most family historians combine two or three of them.
- Record websites (Ancestry, MyHeritage, Findmypast) are first of all for searching: records indexed by name, other researchers' trees, automatic matches. You pay for access to the collections.
- Desktop software (Family Tree Maker, RootsMagic, Gramps) is for keeping the tree: detailed entries, sources, charts and reports. The tree lives on your computer, which is reassuring, but makes working together harder.
- Shared world trees (FamilySearch, WikiTree, Geni) aim at a single tree of humankind: everyone links their ancestors to everyone else's, and anyone can change them.
- Private family trees, such as Ascendance: one tree per family, seen by its members only, which everyone adds to from their phone or computer.
The main tools compared
| Tool | Kind | Cost | Strengths | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ancestry | Website and app, DNA tests | Subscription | The largest collections of records from the UK, Ireland, the US, Canada and Australia | Most records and features need a subscription |
| MyHeritage | Website and app, DNA tests | Limited free plan, subscription | Automatic matches with other trees and records, strong in Europe | The free tree is limited in size and features |
| Findmypast | Website, record collections | Subscription | British and Irish records, including the 1921 census of England and Wales | Made for searching more than for keeping the tree |
| FamilySearch | Website and app, one world tree | Free | Huge collections of record images and indexes from around the world | One shared tree: any member can change your ancestors |
| WikiTree | Website, one world tree | Free | A community that insists on sources, and DNA-confirmed links | Profiles are public and shared with the community |
| Geneanet | Website and app, online trees | Free, Premium option | Volunteer transcriptions and member trees, strongest in France and Europe | Trees are meant to be shared with the community |
| Family Tree Maker | Desktop software (Windows, Mac) | Paid licence | A full desktop program that syncs with an Ancestry tree | Built for one person at one computer |
| RootsMagic | Desktop software (Windows, Mac) | Free Essentials, paid full version | Detailed sources and reports, works alongside the big websites | Working together means exchanging files |
| Gramps | Free and open-source software (Windows, Mac, Linux) | Free | Very powerful, open, independent of any company | A demanding interface; sharing it online (Gramps Web) needs a server |
| Ascendance | Web, iPhone, iPad, Mac, Android | Free, no ads | The family's private tree, built together with roles; Sosa numbers, relationships, wheel, map, timeline | No records database or DNA; research leads open searches on public sites, mostly French; sign in with Google or Apple |
Plans and prices change often: check them on each publisher's site before subscribing.
Questions to ask before choosing
Alone or with the family?
If you research alone, desktop software or a record website is enough. If you want your parents, brothers and sisters or cousins to add what they know, you need a tool where everyone has an account and a role: who reads, who edits, who manages. See building a family tree together.
Public or private?
A tree published online helps other researchers find you, but it also exposes your living relatives, their dates and their photos. Check who sees the tree, whether living people are hidden, and whether the publisher lives on advertising or on selling data.
On which device?
The oldest members of the family rarely have a computer, but almost all have a phone. A tool that works in the browser and on iPhone, iPad and Android lets everyone take part, and shows the tree at the family dinner.
Do you need to pay to search?
Many records are free: national and regional archives, FamilySearch, volunteer transcriptions. Subscriptions save time (search by name, indexed collections); they are not essential to start.
Can you leave with your data?
This is the most important question, and the most forgotten. A good tool exports the whole tree as GEDCOM, which every other program reads. Without that export, years of research stay locked in a subscription.
Combining tools
A very common way of working: search records on archive sites and record websites, check your brick walls on FamilySearch or WikiTree, and keep your reference tree in a single tool, the one where you note your sources. The GEDCOM file is the bridge: you import a cousin's tree, you export yours to publish it elsewhere.
Where Ascendance fits
Ascendance is a private family tree, free and without ads, on the web, on iPhone, iPad, Mac and Android, in English, French, Spanish, Italian, German and Polish. It sells no access to records: it helps the family keep what it knows, and prove it.
- Together: everyone gets a role (viewer, editor, administrator), viewers suggest corrections, and the history keeps every change.
- Worked out for you: Sosa numbers, relationships spelled out, pedigree collapse, duplicates and impossible dates flagged.
- Several views: the tree, the ancestor wheel, the map of places and the timeline; see viewing a family tree.
- Your data stays yours: GEDCOM import and export, JSON and PDF export at any time.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best free genealogy software?
It depends on the use: Gramps is the most complete free desktop program, FamilySearch the richest source of free records, and Ascendance the simplest way to build a private tree together, on the web and on phones. All three read and write GEDCOM.
Do I need a subscription to build my family tree?
No. Many records are free to view in national and regional archives and on FamilySearch, and several free tools keep the tree. A subscription mostly saves time, with records indexed by name.
Can I change genealogy software without typing everything again?
Yes: export the tree as a GEDCOM file from the old tool and import it into the new one. Photos do not travel in the file. Read the GEDCOM guide.
Which genealogy app should I use on iPhone or Android?
Ancestry, MyHeritage, FamilySearch and Geneanet have apps tied to their websites. Ascendance is a free app for iPhone, iPad, Mac and Android, and also works in the browser.
Will strangers see my family tree?
On community websites, trees are often visible to other members, with the option of hiding living people. On FamilySearch and WikiTree, the tree is shared by all. In Ascendance, the tree is seen only by family members accepted by an administrator, and never indexed by search engines.